Case Studies on Issue of Debentures & Public Deposits (Ch 4 & 5) | 12th HSC S.P.

🚨 SMART STUDY ALERT: HOW TO SCORE 3/3 IN CASE STUDIES!

Dear Students, for Question 3 (Case Study / Situation), you DO NOT need to write paragraphs! Each sub-question carries 1 Mark. Just write a direct 1-sentence answer (Yes/No with a small reason or exact concept name) as shown in the blue boxes below to score full marks in 2 minutes!

Below are the most expected, high-probability Case Study questions from Chapter 4 (Issue of Debentures) and Chapter 5 (Deposits).


Case Study 1 (From Chapter 4: Issue of Debentures)

Situation: 'Global Ventures Ltd.' issued a prospectus inviting the public to subscribe for Secured Debentures. Over 1,000 retail investors applied for the issue. The Board of Directors also decided to grant normal voting rights to these debenture holders.
Questions:
a) Is the company's decision to grant voting rights to debenture holders legally valid?
b) Since 1,000 investors applied, does the company need to appoint Debenture Trustees?
c) What is the legal document signed between the company and the trustees called?

🏆 EXAM FOCUS: Direct 1-Sentence Answers!

  • Ans (a): No, the decision is not valid because under Section 71(2) of the Companies Act, a company cannot issue debentures carrying voting rights.
  • Ans (b): Yes, it is mandatory to appoint Debenture Trustees because the number of subscribers exceeds 500.
  • Ans (c): The legal document is called a "Debenture Trust Deed" (Form SH-12).

Case Study 2 (From Chapter 5: Acceptance of Deposits)

Situation: 'Mega Industries Ltd.' is a public company having a Net Worth of Rs. 80 Crores and a Turnover of Rs. 600 Crores. The company wants to accept deposits from the general public for a period of 4 years.
Questions:
a) Is 'Mega Industries Ltd.' an Eligible Public Company?
b) Can the company accept deposits for a period of 4 years?
c) Within how many days should the company issue a deposit receipt to the depositors?

🏆 EXAM FOCUS: Direct 1-Sentence Answers!

  • Ans (a): Yes, it is an Eligible Public Company because its turnover exceeds Rs. 500 Crores.
  • Ans (b): No, a company can accept deposits for a maximum period of 36 months (3 years) only.
  • Ans (c): The company must issue the deposit receipt within 21 days from the receipt of money.