12th Economics Agree or Disagree with Reasons: Q.4 (12 Marks) Board Exam 2027
Welcome to our high-scoring master guide for Question 4: State with Reasons Whether You Agree or Disagree for 12th Standard HSC Economics. In the Maharashtra State Board (MSBSHSE) examination, Question 4 carries 12 Marks, requiring students to attempt any 3 out of 5 statements (4 Marks each). This section is a favourite among toppers because the marking scheme guarantees 1 mark simply for taking the correct stand!
💡 Official Board Marking Scheme Alert (1 + 3 = 4 Marks):
• 1 Mark is awarded strictly for writing the opening declaration: "Yes, I agree with the above statement" or "No, I disagree with the above statement." (Warning: If you write the correct reasons but forget to write whether you agree or disagree, or if your stand is wrong, your entire answer may be marked zero!)
• 3 Marks are awarded for writing at least 3 to 4 valid, point-wise reasons justifying your stand.
1. The scope of Micro Economics is unlimited. (Chapter 1)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement.
Reasons:
- Limited to Individual Units: The word 'Micro' is derived from the Greek word 'Mikros' which means small. Thus, the scope of micro economics is strictly limited to the study of small, individual economic units like an individual consumer, firm, or household.
- Confined to Three Core Theories: The scope of micro economics is mainly confined to three areas: (a) Theory of Product Pricing, (b) Theory of Factor Pricing (Rent, Wages, Interest, Profit), and (c) Theory of Economic Welfare.
- Ignores Macro-Economic Aggregates: Micro economics does not study national-level or aggregate economic problems such as poverty, unemployment, inflation, population growth, and economic growth.
- Ignores Macro Policies: Crucial government policies such as Fiscal Policy, Monetary Policy, and Foreign Trade Policy are completely outside the scope of micro economics. Therefore, its scope is limited, not unlimited.
2. There are no exceptions to the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility (DMU). (Chapter 2)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (There are several exceptions to the Law of DMU).
Reasons:
- Hobbies: In the case of certain hobbies like collection of old coins, rare stamps (philately), or paintings, every additional unit gives more pleasure and increases Marginal Utility (MU). However, this violates the assumption of homogeneity and continuity.
- Miser: For a miser, every additional rupee acquired gives him more and more satisfaction. Thus, the marginal utility of money tends to increase with an increase in his stock of money, though this behaviour violates the assumption of rationality.
- Addictions: In the case of habitual addicts (like drunkards), the level of intoxication and perceived utility increases with every additional peg of liquor consumed, violating the assumption of rationality.
- Power and Money: When a person acquires power, their lust for power increases. Similarly, the MU of money never becomes zero because money is a medium of exchange used to satisfy various wants. Hence, these are considered exceptions (though Apparent Exceptions) to the Law of DMU.
3. Demand curve slopes downward from left to right. (Chapter 3A)
Answer: Yes, I agree with the above statement.
Reasons:
- Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility: A consumer tends to equate the Marginal Utility (MU) of a commodity with its price. As a consumer buys more units, the MU diminishes; therefore, a consumer will buy additional units only when the price falls.
- Income Effect: When the price of a commodity falls, the purchasing power (real income) of the consumer increases. This enables the consumer to buy more of that commodity with the same money income.
- Substitution Effect: In the case of substitute goods (like tea and coffee), when the price of a commodity falls, it becomes relatively cheaper compared to its substitute. Consumers substitute the cheaper good for the dearer one, increasing its demand.
- Multi-purpose Uses: When a commodity can be used for satisfying several needs (like electricity or milk), a fall in its price induces consumers to put it to various less urgent uses, causing the demand curve to slope downward from left to right.
4. Price is the only determinant of demand. (Chapter 3A)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (Apart from price, several other factors determine demand).
Reasons:
- Income of the Consumer: Income determines the purchasing power of a consumer. A rise in income leads to an increase in demand for normal goods, even if the price remains constant.
- Prices of Substitute and Complementary Goods: Demand for a commodity is heavily influenced by changes in the prices of its substitutes (tea and coffee) and complementary goods (car and fuel).
- Size of Population: Larger the size of the population, greater is the market demand for commodities, and vice-versa, irrespective of price changes.
- Tastes, Habits, and Fashions: If a commodity is in fashion or matches the taste and habit of consumers, its demand increases even at a higher price. Other factors like taxation policy, advertisement, and expectations about future prices also determine demand.
5. When the price of Giffen goods falls, the demand for it increases. (Chapter 3A)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (When the price of Giffen goods falls, the demand for it decreases).
Reasons:
- Inferior Quality Goods: Giffen goods refer to inferior quality goods (like coarse grain, jowar, or vanaspati) consumed mostly by low-income households.
- Sir Robert Giffen's Observation: Sir Robert Giffen observed in England that when the price of bread (an inferior good) declined, low-paid workers did not buy more of it.
- Rise in Real Income: When the price of an inferior good falls, the real income (purchasing power) of the poor consumer increases, allowing them to save some money.
- Shift to Superior Goods: Instead of buying more of the inferior good, consumers use their increased real income to purchase superior quality goods (like meat or wheat). Thus, a fall in price leads to a fall in demand, and the demand curve slopes upward from left to right.
6. There are no exceptions to the Law of Supply. (Chapter 4)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (There are several exceptions to the Law of Supply).
Reasons:
- Supply of Labour (Backward Bending Supply Curve): Initially, as the wage rate rises, the supply of labour (hours of work) increases. However, beyond a certain point, a further rise in wages induces workers to prefer leisure over work, causing the supply of labour to fall at higher wages.
- Agricultural Goods: The production and supply of agricultural goods depend heavily on natural climatic conditions (monsoon). If there is a drought or flood, the supply of agricultural goods cannot be increased even if their market prices rise sharply.
- Urgent Need for Cash: If a seller is in urgent need of hard cash, they may be forced to sell more quantity of goods even at a lower price (below the market price), violating the Law of Supply.
- Perishable and Rare Goods: In the case of perishable goods (like milk, fish, vegetables), sellers must sell the stock immediately even if prices fall to avoid total loss. Similarly, the supply of rare goods (ancient coins, old paintings) is fixed and cannot be increased even at a very high price.
7. Seller is the price maker under Perfect Competition. (Chapter 5)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (Under Perfect Competition, the seller is a Price Taker, not a Price Maker).
Reasons:
- Large Number of Sellers: Under perfect competition, there are so many sellers that each individual seller supplies only a negligible fraction of the total market supply. Hence, no single seller can influence the market price by changing their supply.
- Homogeneous Product: All sellers sell completely identical (homogeneous) products. If any individual seller tries to charge a slightly higher price, buyers will immediately shift to other sellers.
- Perfect Knowledge of Market: Buyers have complete knowledge of the prevailing uniform market price, making it impossible for any seller to overcharge.
- Price Determined by Market Forces: The equilibrium price is determined by the industry through the interaction of total market demand and total market supply. Individual firms must accept this price and sell their output; hence, the seller is a Price Taker.
8. Index numbers are free from limitations. (Chapter 6)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (Index numbers suffer from several practical limitations).
Reasons:
- Based on Samples: Index numbers are generally based on a small sample of items rather than the entire population. Therefore, they are not completely free from sampling errors.
- Bias in the Data: Index numbers are constructed from various types of data collected by different agencies. There may be errors or deliberate manipulation in the base year or current year data, leading to biased results.
- Defects in Formulae: There is no single perfect formula for constructing an index number. Each formula (Laspeyre's, Paasche's) is only an average and has its own mathematical limitations.
- Changes in the Economy (Qualitative Changes): With the passage of time, the habits, tastes, and expectations of people change, and new superior quality products are introduced. Index numbers fail to account for these qualitative improvements in products.
9. There are many theoretical difficulties in the measurement of National Income. (Chapter 7)
Answer: Yes, I agree with the above statement.
Reasons:
- Transfer Payments: Individuals receive pensions, scholarships, and unemployment allowances. Although it is personal income for the recipient, it is difficult to separate it as it is a mere transfer of money without any productive economic activity.
- Illegal Income: Income earned through illegal activities like gambling, black marketing, smuggling, and theft has value and satisfies wants, but it is excluded from National Income as it is not socially recognised.
- Unpaid Services: National income only considers paid goods and services. Services rendered out of love, affection, and sympathy—such as the services of housewives or social workers—are excluded due to the difficulty of assigning a monetary value.
- Changing Price Levels: Difficulties arise due to fluctuations in price levels. When the price level rises, National Income may show an artificial increase even though the actual physical output (real production) has decreased.
10. Obligatory function is the only function of the Government. (Chapter 8)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (The Government performs both Obligatory and Optional functions).
Reasons:
- Meaning of Obligatory Functions: Obligatory functions refer to compulsory duties of the government, such as protection from external attack (defence) and maintaining internal law and order.
- Shift to Welfare State: A modern government is not merely a 'police state' restricted to defence and justice; it is a 'Welfare State' committed to promoting the socio-economic welfare of its citizens.
- Provision of Education and Health Services: Under optional functions, the government spends heavily on building schools, universities, public hospitals, and running free vaccination drives to improve human capital.
- Social Security and Public Utilities: The government also provides social security measures like old-age pensions, widow pensions, public transport, water supply, and electricity. Thus, optional functions are equally important alongside obligatory functions.
11. Commercial banks cannot create credit. (Chapter 9)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (Credit creation is one of the most important functions of commercial banks).
Reasons:
- Primary Deposits as the Base: Commercial banks accept deposits from the public, which are known as 'Primary Deposits'. These deposits form the foundation for creating credit in the economy.
- Maintenance of Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR): Banks know from experience that all depositors do not withdraw their money at the same time. Hence, banks keep a small fraction of primary deposits as minimum cash reserves (CRR) as directed by the RBI.
- Advancing Loans: After keeping the required cash reserve, commercial banks lend the remaining excess funds to borrowers and businessmen for investment purposes.
- Creation of Secondary (Derivative) Deposits: When a bank grants a loan, instead of giving hard cash, it opens a deposit account in the name of the borrower and credits the loan amount to it. This creates a 'Secondary Deposit' or 'Derivative Deposit'. Through this cycle, commercial banks create credit multiple times their primary deposits.
12. Balance of Payments is the same as Balance of Trade. (Chapter 10)
Answer: No, I disagree with the above statement. (Balance of Payments and Balance of Trade are two distinct concepts).
Reasons:
- Difference in Meaning: Balance of Trade (BOT) is the difference between the value of a country's exports and imports of visible goods only for a given period. Balance of Payments (BOP) is a systematic record of all international economic transactions of a country with the rest of the world during a year.
- Visible vs. Invisible Items: Balance of Trade includes only visible goods (merchandise like machinery, clothes, oil). Balance of Payments includes both visible goods and invisible services (banking, shipping, insurance, tourism) as well as capital transfers.
- Scope of the Concept: Balance of Trade is a narrower concept, whereas Balance of Payments is a much broader and comprehensive concept.
- Part vs. Whole: Balance of Trade is merely one component (part) of the Current Account of the Balance of Payments. Therefore, both concepts are not the same.
📌 Continue Your Economics Preparation
With Question 4 completed, you have covered 50 marks of the paper! Now let's move on to the most scoring application-based section using the links below: